Cowper’s Cut 443: Upcoming themes
’Cut’ readers are aware of (and I believe, value) the fact that when a fairly inconsequential week in English health policy and politics comes along, I do not bother to pretend otherwise.
This has been another such week. It has, also, been the middle of August.
As such, a few brief bits of abstract zoomed-out thought seems reasonable, so here it comes. These will be among the most important themes for the upcoming couple of years. Brace yourselves!
Centralisation versus decentralisation
Shouldn’t need too much explanation to ‘Cut’ readers: I have been banging on about the dialectical trends here for some time now.
Centralisation of NHS power is massively happening, despite NHS England chair Penny Dash’s curious denial of this obvious fact, yet Mascara Kid and new PM Andy Burnham is a professed decentraliser.
This is not likely to add up successfully.
And the Health Bill is currently at Report Stage. You can read its text here.
Assuming that you are in your right mind, you cannot look down its schedule of themes and think that this Bill is about decentralising power within the English NHS.
It is entirely possible, and may be probable, that the Burnham Administration plans to deal with the obvious incoherence between the political reality of legislation centralising power over the NHS and their rhetoric about the vital importance of decentralisation by ignoring it.
In the shortest of terms, this may work. An extremely policy-illiterate opposition such as that of the current Conservative And Unionist Party will facilitate this - but only in the very short term, until the symptoms appear.
That will not prevent the cracks from opening up when reality meets legislation, i.e. in the very near future.
The proposals for Advanced Foundation Trusts are, essentially, nonsensically weak versions of the original freedoms offered to NHS FTs, with even weaker arrangements for public accountability. Yes, most FTs did not optimise their memberships (can you imagine how effective a well-organised ‘National Trust’-like NHS collective membership body might have been?), but what the 2026 legislation offers is even weaker still.
There remains no meaningful proposed 2026 equivalent of FTs’ financial freedoms in the original iteration. And it is worth reviewing Ben Collins’ 2016 article for The Kings Fund about the slow strangulation of FT independence, back in the day.
I surely don’t need to remind ‘Cut’ readers that when you want a thing to happen in the English NHS, then you first need to create a system with effective and durable financial incentives for that thing to happen; and alongside this, you need to put in measurement and checks and balances that this desired new good thing does not create negative externalities as a consequence.
There is no evidence that this crucial bit of system planing has been done: either for RTT and other waiting list backlog reduction, or for the ‘triple shift’ preventative ambitions.
Without the right incentives, the English NHS health policy agenda is merely well-meaning but ineffectual rhetoric. It is not at all clear that anyone in Team Mascara has even started to think about this: they need to do so, with some urgency and ideally, a few people who have actual brains and knowledge of the patch.
Buildings and estates
“Oh, how frightfully analogue!”, the AI Apostles of the Tony Blair Institute will be saying. Don’t we know that AI is here to save the NHS?
Mmmmmmm. Seems unlikely that these people have spent much time in NHS buildings in the recent three-month heatwave. Where 41 degree Celsius indoor temperatures have been a fact of life.
This comes on top of the backlog maintenance bill having hit £16 billion in last October’s Estates Returns Information Collection data (and so a fair bit more now), and us having no actual plan to deal with any of this.
It seems likely that a high-profile fatality is going to be needed to bring attention to this, in much the way that Lord Winston’s mother’s appalling experience in Charing Cross Hospital in the winter of 1999 led in part to ‘The Most Expensive Breakfast In History’.
This is obviously going to be a great year for installers of air conditioning: invest in the major suppliers today. All of our society is dangerously underprepared for a warming world: the NHS is not excepted.
Included in this ongoing neglect of the physical conditions for delivering healthcare is the total failure to begin to manage the upcoming ending of the Private Finance Initiative contracts, that began under the John Major government and rebuilt much of the NHS estate under Blair and Brown.

This is really not new news in the slightest, but what has been done at the national (centralised) level to prepare for it in any meaningful way at all?
Absolutely nothing.
Zip.
Zero.
This is going to be a massive story, very soon indeed.
The English NHS workforce
They’re still there (well, a fair number of them).
They’re still really pissed off.
And it would be difficult to assert that the current national English NHS leadership has expended a great deal of its FDC (Fuck Donation Capacity) on the subject.
This will need to change, because if the threatened industrial action by consultants hoves into view (and the current BMA leadership is comfortably politically stupid enough to let this happen), the smelly organic brown stuff will hit the mechanical rotating thing in no uncertain terms.
There are considerations here: it is highly likely that there will be a new push on physician associates, despite the utter and shameful failure of the last attempt to crowbar this through the professions that led to the infamous 2024 Royal College of Physicians EGM.
How this is approached will be a critical issue. It is hard to have confidence that the lessons from the last attempt have been meaningfully learned. So ‘etonne-nous, Cocteau!’ It would be very agreeable to be surprised on the upside by a more enlightened approach: one that perhaps learns something from what demonstrably worked extremely well with pharmacy technicians.
Recommended and required reading
The Financial Times reports that the UK government has increased the projected cost of the NHS England Federated Data Platform built by Palantir, and revised down the expected financial benefits.

Ooops! Health Service Journal reports that Treasury-born National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority’s latest assessment of the benefit value of the Federated Data Plaform over its lifetime is £808 million: this is curiously a chunky £1.7 billion less than the figure given by NHS England a year ago. How could NHS England have got that number so seriously wrong? It’s a mystery.
New Health But Social Care Secretary Yvette Cooper thinks that the NHS has a discharge problem, apparently. Because systems don’t work together.
Another fine HSJ Mythbuster column from Steve Black on the dangers of slopulist policy.
The next time you’re encouraged to believe that ‘Treasury’ are some high-functioning department of geniuses, just remember this.


